Keeping Animals in Zoos is Cruel

86

By theherbivorehippi

Animals in the Zoo Are Stripped of Control Over their Lives

"Freedom is a precious concept and wild animals suffer physically and mentally from the lack of freedom captivity imposes." -Born Free star McKenna Honoured 31 Dec 2003

ZOOS ARE NOT EDUCATIONAL

An animal held in captivity can never be viewed in its natural state. Observing an animal's wild and natural habitat can never be achieved in an unnatural environment. Zoos are prisons to animals. Animals held captive in zoos cannot roam fly, climb, choose a partner or live freely or naturally. They are captive, bored, cramped, lonely and have been stripped of control over their natural lives!

People will argue zoos are educational but visitors on average spend only a few minutes at each display, learning nothing about the animals, seeing the same thing they can see on television. Signs generally only post the species and diet. Animals are captive for this? There is nothing natural about the environment of a zoo. Bird's wings are clipped so they can't fly, aquatic animals don't have the amount of water they need and animals who in the wild live in herds are kept alone or at the most in pairs. These animals are closely confined with no privacy and lack mental stimulation and exercise. Zoochosis often sets in resulting in abnormal and self destructive behavior. Lions and bears will walk continuously in circles, elephants and giraffes will bang their heads on the bars and monkeys will turn to self-mutilation. How is observing an animal in this state remotely educational?

Zoos say they want to protect certain species from extinction but in actuality they favor popular animals that draw a crowd. Most animals are not endangered and the ones that are will never be released into their wild habitat. Money spent on zoo ticket purchases pay for animals to be imprisoned and traded, not rescued and rehabilitated. Zoos continue to capture animals from the wild to put on display and are pressuring the federal government to weaken the Endangered species act to make it easier for them to capture and import animals. Zoos routinely trade, loan and barter adult animals they don't want anymore. The Chinese government rents pandas to zoos all over the world for millions of dollars per year with questions arising constantly if the profits go toward panda conservation at all. It is a fact that an African elephant in a zoo will have an average lifespan of 16.9 years, the same animal in it's wild and natural habitat has a lifespan of 56. Many zoos are realizing this and closing their elephant exhibits. The Detroit zoo, where I live sent their elephants to a sanctuary realizing elephants should not live in small groups and should never have to suffer cold winters in the north.

As zoo funds are cut, cages are smaller with less foliage. The red panda,almost an extinct animal is kept at the Bronx zoo, a few hundred feet from the cars zooming by on the expressway constantly with only a fence to separate them. How is an animal so endangered kept in such a careless environment. These animals are being used for human entertainment. Their true natural way of life can never be learned in these conditions.



ANIMALS DESERVE FREEDOM

An elephant in the wild has a natural lifespan of 56 years.  In the zoo, the average is 16.9 years.
An elephant in the wild has a natural lifespan of 56 years. In the zoo, the average is 16.9 years.

ANIMALS HAVE NO CONTROL OVER THEIR LIVES

Animals held in captivity cannot roam, fly or choose a partner.
Animals held in captivity cannot roam, fly or choose a partner.

HOW MANY ANIMALS MUST DIE IN ZOOS?

Not only is an animal's freedom taken away being held captive in a zoo, their chance for survival is no longer their control.

** Tatiana, a Siberian tiger, escaped her enclosure at the San Francisco zoo in 2007 and was shot and killed after she 'naturally' killed someone and injured two others.

** Jabari, a gorilla, tried to escape the Dallas zoo by jumping the wall and evading electrified wires. Police shot it. Witnesses later said teenagers were taunting the animal, throwing rocks at it.

** Two polar bears, Churchill and Penny died within five weeks of each other at the Saint Louis zoo. Churchill died after eating an object thrown in his exhibit and Penny died, having two dead fetuses in her uterus.

** At the Virgina zoo 10 prairie dogs died when their tunnel collapsed, a rhino drowned in the moat of her exhibit and a zebra died after running into a fence and breaking her neck after receiving a rabies shot.

** The Minnesota petting zoo farm sells their animals off to livestock auctions once the babies grow up and lose their appeal to the public.

** The Buffalo zoo, most disturbing of these examples has constant cases of neglect and several animals dead in the past few years. Four polar bears died over a 10 month time period. Kinapak ate a black garbage bag and a rat bait block. Becky, after an autopsy, was found to have plastic rims in her stomach. Kelly's autopsy revealed stone material and a plastic toy in her stomach. Danny, who had been anesthetized was suppose to be supervised. He was left alone for two hours and found dead at the bottom of his pool. In May of 2005 a seal died while being transported from heat distress caused by a lack of sufficient ice or cooling water. A hyena was found crushed by a boulder in May of 2007.

These are only a handful of examples and zoos in foreign countries have an even higher death toll. A zoo can never be thought of as educational. A human being can never learn anything about a wild animals observing it in a state that their behavior is controlled and depressed. Wild animals are required to have human interaction. THIS IS THE ULTIMATE DISRESPECT OF THE SPECIES. Their eyes hold a lifetime of sadness and emptiness as they are stared at, aggravated by camera flashes and taunted. Shame on the human race for finding this acceptable.

WHAT ARE YOUR THOUGHTS?

Do you feels zoos are educational?

  • Absoluletly not! Animals should be in the wild.
  • Yup....I've learned a thing or two at the zoo.
  • I'm on the fence. I think animals deserve to be in the wild but i feel zoos teach us too.
See results without voting

THE ALMOST EXTINCT RED PANDA

The almost extinct red panda is kept at the Bronx zoo hundreds of feet away from cars zooming by at all hours, separated only by a fence.  Is this how an endangered species should be kept?
The almost extinct red panda is kept at the Bronx zoo hundreds of feet away from cars zooming by at all hours, separated only by a fence. Is this how an endangered species should be kept?

FUN LION GIFTS

Secondhand Lions
Amazon Price: $2.91
List Price: $5.97
Face to Face with Lions (Face to Face with Animals)
Amazon Price: $3.13
List Price: $6.95
Lion (Close Up) Art Poster Print - 24x36 Poster Print, 24x36
Amazon Price: $0.92
List Price: $9.99
Schleich Lion 14373
Amazon Price: $3.58
List Price: $6.00
Lions - Deluxe Boxt Set
Amazon Price: $18.90
List Price: $29.99

FOR THE ELEPHANT LOVER

Fabulous Hong Tze Collection-Mini Elephant
Amazon Price: $0.20
ELEPHANT Crystal Necklace in Pink Elephant Gift Box
Amazon Price: $5.95
List Price: $19.99
The Elephant Whisperer: My Life with the Herd in the African Wild
Amazon Price: $11.55
List Price: $16.99
Snow Globe Elephant Collection Desk Figurine Figure Desk Decoration
Amazon Price: $15.99
List Price: $25.99
Ty Beanie Boos - Peanut the Elephant(6 inch)
Amazon Price: $1.69
List Price: $7.99

LOVE TO HEAR FEEDBACK!

Peter Dickinson profile image

Peter Dickinson Level 3 Commenter 2 years ago

theherbivorehippi - It is an interesting hub and I would not argue with some of your examples because we do not live in a perfect world but you are falling into the same old rut of believing all zoos are the same. They are not. Most animals in zoos were born there and know no better. People working in zoos care far more about animals than those on the outside. No-one is seriously thinking about returning most species to the wild because the wild is in a mess. Zoos do educate and raise more money for wild conservation than other groups. The wild is a very cruel place (although I agree that in a perfect world that that is where animals belong). I suppose I could go on for hours but I won't. One thing I have learnt from 40 years in zoos is that the 'anti-zoo' brigade are not prepared to listen or read the other side of the story. I hope you will read my hubs. Yours was well constructed and researched. Thanks.

Katelyn Weel profile image

Katelyn Weel 2 years ago

I agree with Peter, that Zoos are not all bad.

The Toronto Zoo is hugely involved with conservation efforts, and their animals are kept in spacious habitats. If you've ever walked through it, you'll agree that the place was designed with the well-being of the animals in mind, not just the human visitors.

Also, don't forget that many wild animals are territorial, and consider their zoo enclosures to be their own territory. They are safe from attacks and confrontations and all the brutal struggles of the wild, and I hardly think that's torture. Plus, as Peter pointed out, many of them were born there and don't know any different.

I do agree, however, that many zoos are underfunded and/or drastically under-regulated, or run by greedy capitalists. which means the well being of the animals is less of a priority than making money. It is always infuriating to see animal abuse and the way people disrespect other animals is disgusting.

NOW, I believe the experience of seeing, hearing, touching, and being up close and personal to wild animals in as close to a natural setting as possible is absolutely invaluable in teaching people, especially young people who will eventually have the power to change things, to learn about and respect animals and nature.

Zoos that are properly run are a great educational tool and I don't believe that pictures or movies could possibly have the same effect.

I agree with you on many points, and the examples you gave here are certainly worth pointing out. I hope the people responsible are dealt with and that regulations controlling the treatment of all animals should be taken MUCH more seriously.

Katelyn Weel profile image

Katelyn Weel 2 years ago

Worse things happen in the wild, how about getting eaten alive by a group of lions?

AARON99 profile image

AARON99 2 years ago

This hub reveals the true picture about zoos. Especially, now a days zoos are recognised as one of the most widely seen demostrated place for animals, which should not be happened. Actually, this hub is a powerful punch to this demostrations. All the very best. Keep writing. Enjoy.

theherbivorehippi profile image

theherbivorehippi Hub Author 2 years ago

Thanks for reading Aaron99. I know that some zoos do actually care about their animals and try to provide natural environments to preserve the species but then there are just as many that are neglectful and it is shameful!

michifus profile image

michifus Level 1 Commenter 22 months ago

Its 50/50 for me. Im actually a zoologist, and have studied at zoos quite a bit. Ive gained a lot from the experience, althogh a lot probably don't. Are they bad? it really does rather depend on the zoo. There are a great many zoos which are worse than awful and should be closed down, however good work does take place in some zoos. It really does depend on the zoo in question.

There are some fantastic zoos around, cant speak for the US ones but the Safari parks in the UK are great. The animals are looked after very well, they have a huge area to roam around, and you drive through to get to see them.

Sometimes you cant see very much because the enclosures are so big, other times the animals are really close. Its much more natural, plus the enclosures are a decent size (a few hectares)Would the animals be better in the wild? Yes.

However, valuable research does takes place in some zoos which is good for the species and science. Many have breeding programmes and release animals back into the wild,but these are few and far between. A lot take animals which would otherwise not survive.

There is educational value to be gained, although I appreciate that for most visitors they offer little more than just a day out, and a chance to point at animals, tap cages, pull faces and laugh at them, however it is those people which provide the funding which then gets put into improving enclosures, funding the breeding programmes, and helps with the research.

You learn much more from wildlife documentaries really, however it would be a shame if people lost the opportunity of seeing the animals first hand.

The way we are destroying the planet, a great deal of the species will be extint in the wild anyway, with zoo populations the only way to stop total extinction.

......great hub by the way. I don't disagree with what you have said, the good zoos are probably just 10% of all those which exist, probably a lot less. And even though there are good ones, they are not universally good for all animals.

Should we have them? On balance, probably not. But I for one would think it would be a shame if we lost them.

theherbivorehippi profile image

theherbivorehippi Hub Author 22 months ago

See....I so agree with you. If we could have Less zoos but MORE quality with the ones that are around, that would be ideal. I know I have been to zoos where I watch these animals roam in circles because their enclosures are so small and yes for the most part...people are not learning anything but do take every opportunity to tap on glass, etc...even those there is a sign that clearly says "Do Not Touch Glass". People are morons or else illiterate I guess.

I know that there are a few select zoos that really genuinely care about their animals but then how do we regulate it so ALL zoos have to be this way. Who is held accountable for neglect. It is just so difficult.

Thanks for your comment! It would be a shame to lose all zoos but there has to be a way to change them world wide.

izettl profile image

izettl Level 6 Commenter 20 months ago

Sometimes zoos save animals from their habitat in the wild or from other situations. There are bad and good attributes. It's hardest for me to see the bigger animals in the zoo because I think how magnificent they woudl be in a much larger space and in their natural environment.

I saw the saddest thing ever when i went to our state fair. They had some zoo animals in small cages there for people to view. The lion and tiger looked dead from so much tranquilizer probably- it was awful. My 3 yr old asked what was wrong with them. How do exaplain all that? THe porcupine was prbably one of the only animals not sedated and he was frantically pacing his enclosure. I felt "dirty" for a lack of better word that I was there and happened to see all this.

theherbivorehippi profile image

theherbivorehippi Hub Author 20 months ago

That is such a sad story. See I hate to see and hear things like that. It is so unnecessary. I do agree that some zoos can be useful in preserving some animals but there should be some level of responsibility and accountability for the animals that are clearly unhappy, unhealthy and miserable.

izettl profile image

izettl Level 6 Commenter 20 months ago

You know, what's strange is that I understand zoos help kids learn, but I've actually began disliking zoos more since taking my daughter to them because this is not how I want her to think of animals, all caged up. Of course when she asked what was wrong with the lion and tiget at the state fair then I knew even at her young age she knew something was wrong. Even you and I not trained in knowing this stuff can tell if an animal is unhappy and unhealthy- seems to me more should be done about those situations.

Shalini Kagal profile image

Shalini Kagal Level 4 Commenter 20 months ago

Even if zoos are well kept and well run - the trapped look in the animals and birds' eyes are terrible to see! I see the birds and squirrels outside my window and see how joyful they are - that can never happen in a zoo even if they are fed and looked after with a lot of love and care. Animals need to be carefree and in the wild - just a personal opinion which is why I love this hub!

theherbivorehippi profile image

theherbivorehippi Hub Author 20 months ago

izetti - Isn't it amazing how children can pick up on the concerns and sadness of animals yet adults overlook them. it is truly sad.

Shalini Kagal - I agree....I love that you mention the squirrels. I have two squirrel pets now that I put nuts and seeds out for on a table on my porch everyday and they just sit there and look me in teh window and eat. So adorable. They even have their water bowl. lol I can't imagine a wild animal that is use to being free to all of a sudden be caged.

Germaine Reilly 17 months ago

Zoos are definitely not educational. I've carried out some research into animal circuses and these animals develop worrying behaviour; head nodding, pacing and swaying. I imagine in the worst cases the same behaviour is mirrored by animals in zoos.

Even in the best zoo enclosures, with stimulation and a suitable environment, I still think it's the case that zoo animals aren't able to fulfil their innate selves to the fullest.

Leads and Feeds 17 months ago

Shalini Kagal - you are humanising birds and animals whn you say 'i can see the trapped look in their eyes', although i beleive an animal is always best in the wild, some animals, cannot survive in the wild due to various circumstances. and although lots of Zoo's need severe improvements and stiffer rules, lots of Zoo's have contributed a huge amount to conservation and education for the public, someone said higher up, that people dont use Zoo's for education as they have TV. Lots of the TV shows are done by or at Zoo's! thanks for the information, i found this very interesting.

vicky 15 months ago

I think animals should be kept in zoos at the highest quality because if there are an endangerd species a breeding program would be essential to save the species.

Ignas Nenorta 15 months ago

In my opinon the zoos around are monstrous and should be shut down.Animals dont actually get protected in them,most zoos are built just so the keepers can make money.Most animals get transported so much that only 20% of them actually make it out alive.Zoos just don't have enough respect for the animals they keep.

Umair S Khan profile image

Umair S Khan 14 months ago

The very first time regarding freedom is so very true. One can only imagine what one would have have felt being an animal robbed of freedom.

Tori 8 months ago

Went to the Bronx Zoo today. Hadn't been to a zoo in years. I was appalled at the small confinements most of the animals were kept in. Many herd animals were simply paired up. Many of the environments were poorly designed and disgustingly lacking of space, comfort and natural appeal. Many were even dirty looking. How can I do something about what I saw? To whom do complain? I understand zoos will always exist, but how can ensure that animals lead the highest quality of life possible outside of their natural habitat? Any advice from anyone would be greatly appreciated.

theherbivorehippi profile image

theherbivorehippi Hub Author 8 months ago

It is horrific isn't it? It breaks my heart. There are a lot of petitions and people trying to change things on the Care2 website, Changes.org and many other sites. It's so sad. One bear was just rescued from a bile farmer than has been in a small cage in China for 30 YEARS!! If you're on twitter you can follow me...I'm under herbivorehippie. I promote petitions all day long. Every signature helps. Thanks for sharing your experience. The more people that become aware of these conditions, the better!

You may want to google Tony the Tiger in Louisiana as well. This is a tiger being kept in a cage at a truck stop, breathing in fumes all day. The court day is set for September 15th to get him out of there, if you can sign the petition it would be great!

Gloshei profile image

Gloshei Level 5 Commenter 8 months ago

There are good ones and bad ones, the good ones do so much for rare species and try to educate the public. These are the ones we should promote.

I have just written about Cincinatti Zoo it's worth taking a look.

Great Hub'

..... 7 months ago

zoos are cruel places for animals to live in its like a jail

kaden bengam 5 months ago

it is really cruel to keep animals in zoo's.

ice 3 weeks ago

the zoos are crel too animals and should be closed and all of the animals should be set free

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working